On March 28, 2016, the Supreme Court of California issued another ruling on the enforceability of arbitration agreements. In Baltazar v. Forever 21, Inc. (S208345), the court considered the enforceability of an arbitration agreement authorizing the parties to seek provisional relief in a judicial action while still compelling the remainder of the dispute to arbitration. According to the court, the clause carving out provisional relief from the arbitration obligation “which does no more than restate existing law . . . does not render the agreement unconscionable.”  Moreover, the court reiterated that an arbitration agreement remains enforceable even when it only lists claims that would likely be brought by an employee and does not list claims that might be brought by an employer. The decision provides much needed clarity and flexibility to employers implementing arbitration agreements in California.

Background

In 2007, Maribel Baltazar completed an employment application to work at a warehouse operated by Forever 21, a retail merchandiser. The application included an arbitration agreement, which Baltazar signed, requiring the parties to arbitrate claims or actions arising out of or related to hiring, employment, remuneration, and separation.

In 2011, Baltazar resigned from her job and later sued Forever 21 for harassment, discrimination, and retaliation. Forever 21 filed a motion to compel arbitration, which Baltazar opposed, arguing the agreement was unconscionable.

The trial court found that the agreement was unconscionable. On appeal, a California Court of Appeal found that the agreement was procedurally unconscionable but not substantively unconscionable. The Supreme Court of California agreed to hear the case and affirmed the decision of the Court of Appeal.

The Supreme Court’s Decision

Baltazar presented one claim of procedural unconscionablity and three claims of substantive unconscionability.

Procedural Unconscionablity

Baltazar asserted that Forever 21 provided the agreement to her upon her hire, telling her that she had to sign it or Forever 21 would not hire her. Baltazar asserted that the level of procedural unconscionablity was particularly high, however, because the arbitration agreement stated that any arbitration would be governed by the American Arbitration Association’s (AAA) rules, but did not attach the rules to the arbitration agreement. The facts of this case raise an issue as to whether an employer must attach the arbitration rules that govern an agreement to the agreement, or whether incorporating them by reference is enough to avoid procedural unconscionability.

Rather than squarely decide this issue, the Supreme Court of California noted the cases that invalidated agreements that did not have the rules attached to them and stated that Baltazar’s position “might have force if her unconscionability challenge concerned some element of the AAA rules of which she had been unaware when she signed the arbitration agreement.” Because, however, her substantive unconscionability challenges were related to the arbitration agreement itself, and not the AAA rules, the employer’s failure to attach the rules had no impact on the court’s consideration of whether the agreement was substantively unconscionable.  

Substantive Unconscionablity

(1)  Provisional Relief

The parties’ agreement permitted them to bring a judicial action to seek provisional relief (such as a temporary restraining order or preliminary injunctive relief) in addition to arbitration. According to Baltazar, this provision unfairly favored Forever 21 because an employer is, Baltazar claimed, more likely than its employees to seek provisional relief. While accepting, arguendo, that an employer is more likely to seek provisional relief than an employee, the court rejected prior decisions that held that such a limited carve-out provision rendered the agreement substantively unconscionable. In arriving at this conclusion, the court relied upon California Code of Civil Procedure section 1281.8(b), “which expressly permits parties to an arbitration to seek preliminary injunctive relief during the pendency of the arbitration.” Because the statute provides for a provisional relief carve out, the court held that it was not substantively unconscionable. According to the court, “the clause merely confirms, rather than expands, rights available to the parties under that code section.”

(2)  One-Sided: Only Employee’s Claims Listed

Baltazar noted that examples of disputes that are subject to arbitration under the agreement “include but are not limited to” claims for wages, contract breaches, discrimination, retaliation, harassment, and others. Based on this language, Baltazar argued that the arbitration agreement was unfairly one-sided because it listed only claims that would be brought by employees as examples of the types of claims that are subject to arbitration—leaving “in doubt whether the kinds of claims employers typically bring are also subject to arbitration.”

The court again sided with Forever 21. According to the court, the agreement required the parties to arbitrate all employment-related claims and thus that the agreement “clearly covers claims an employer might bring as well as those an employee might bring.” The examples of claims provided in the agreement, the court noted, do not “render the agreement sufficiently unfair as to make its enforcement unconscionable.”

(3)  One-Sided: Trade Secrets Provision

Baltazar next points to a provision in the agreement that required both parties to agree that during arbitration “all necessary steps will be taken” to protect from disclosure the company’s trade secrets and proprietary and confidential information. According to Baltazar, by failing to define “all necessary steps” and “proprietary and confidential information,” “the agreement unfairly demands that employees take whatever steps the employer deems ‘necessary’ to protect whatever information the employer claims to be ‘proprietary and confidential’”—making the agreement unduly one-sided.

The court, once again, disagreed. According to the court, “[n]othing in the agreement indicates that an employee must accede to any and all demands Forever 21 might make for the protection of confidential and proprietary information.” Agreements to protect sensitive information, the court found, “are a regular feature of modern litigation, and they carry with them no inherent unfairness.”

Thus, the Supreme Court of California concluded that the arbitration agreement was not unconscionable and was enforceable.

Key Takeaways

Baltazar provides important guidance to employers seeking to implement arbitration agreements with their employees, but have concerns about potentially waiving their rights to seek provisional relief in court. In exigent situations, there may not be time to convene an arbitrator before suffering irreparable harm. Before Baltazar, there was a line of cases that seemed to indicate that carving out claims for provisional relief might undermine the enforceability of the entire arbitration agreement. Baltazar indicates that a narrowly drafted carve-out may be enforceable. However, Baltazar also indicates that the Supreme Court of California will continue to look very carefully at arbitration agreements, necessitating careful and prudent drafting.

Authors


Browse More Insights

Practice Group

Global Reorganizations

Organizations may need to restructure their workforces for a number of reasons. These include mergers and acquisitions, post-merger integrations (PMI), cost-cutting initiatives, and reorganizations of group structure to improve, among other things, business performance, operations, and efficiencies.

Learn more
UK, London, digital composite of city skyscrapers in London financial district with lush green trees
Practice Group

Environmental, Social, and Governance (ESG)

Environmental, Social, and Governance (ESG) initiatives involve unique and sometimes difficult challenges for employers that seek to develop and comply with these initiatives while minimizing the potential for audits, shareholder demands, litigation, and other adverse, reputational outcomes based on these ESG initiatives.

Learn more
Practice Group

Multistate Advice and Counseling

Multistate compliance is a rising challenge for many employers as they expand their business footprints and remote workforces across state lines. Multistate employers are required to comply with various state and local laws that are constantly evolving while also maintaining their workplace culture and meeting their business goals.

Learn more
Practice Group

California Class Action and PAGA

California routinely leads the nation in wage-and-hour class action filings for a number of reasons. California’s wage and hour laws provide a broader range of rights for employees than federal law or the laws of other states. In addition, California’s Labor Code generally allows a successful employee to recover attorneys’ fees, whereas a successful employer is not able to recover fees from the employee.

Learn more
CEO giving peptalk to businesspeople at meeting
Practice Group

Workplace Investigations and Organizational Assessments

Our attorneys draw on investigation and litigation experience to navigate complex complaints. Knowing how issues will be evaluated by a trier of facts—a judge or jury—can be critical. Moreover, we assist employers in evaluating whether the attorney-client privilege applies to investigation communications.

Learn more
Silhouette of a judge's gavel. Cryptocurrencies and legality
Practice Group

Trial

We understand that only a fraction of lawsuits will ever make it to trial. That means that most companies—and their lawyers—have very little actual jury trial experience. So when your case is called to trial, you need a trial team with experience.

Learn more
Fingerprint Biometric Authentication Button. Digital Security Concept
Practice Group

Technology

Ogletree Deakins is uniquely situated to provide tech employers and users (the “TECHPLACE™”) with labor and employment advice, compliance counseling, and litigation services that embrace innovation and mitigate legal risk. Through our Technology Practice Group, we support clients in the exploration, invention, and/or implementation of new and evolving technologies to navigate the unique and emerging labor and employment issues present in the workplace.

Learn more
Industry Group

Financial Services

Our team of attorneys has decades of experience advising and representing a broad spectrum of financial services industry clients and we understand the unique issues that they face. Our clients include banks, SEC-regulated public companies, broker-dealers, employers of investment advisors, FINRA-registered firms and representatives, mortgage companies, hedge funds, and private equity firms.

Learn more
White Semi-Trailer Truck Heading down a four-lane Highway at Dusk delivering a load in the southeastern Utah desert on interstate 70 east bound
Industry Group

Trucking and Logistics

The Ogletree Deakins Trucking and Logistics Industry Group is comprised of an international team of experienced attorneys who advise, counsel, and represent carriers and companies with trucking divisions in all aspects of labor and employment matters affecting drivers and other workers in the trucking and logistics industry.

Learn more
Digital generated image of multi racial group of people forming circle on world map on blue background. Solidarity and support concept.
Practice Group

Diversity and Inclusion

Our attorneys are ready to assist with the full spectrum of workplace D&I-related issues. The members of Ogletree Deakins’ Diversity and Inclusion Practice Group have extensive and unique experience assisting employers in the creation, implementation, and management of D&I programs, including conducting thorough analyses of diversity data and identifying meaningful metrics and benchmarks.

Learn more
Robotic arm and steel conveyor in assembly manufacturing factory.
Industry Group

Manufacturing

Ogletree Deakins knows manufacturing. In its most recent rankings, The BTI Consulting Group recognized Ogletree Deakins as a “Powerhouse” for our outstanding relationships with manufacturing industry clients. This recognition reflected feedback from in-house counsel, who were asked which law firms were both their core, go-to firms and which firms they would recommend most to peers. […]

Learn more
Practice Group

Mergers and Acquisitions

Ogletree Deakins understands that corporate acquisitions and restructurings can be complex and challenging. Clients need a business partner that can help them structure the labor and employment aspects of a transaction in a way that will provide transparent information on the costs of compliance with applicable laws and regulations at every stage of the deal.

Learn more
Practice Group

Background Checks

Background checks are a trending topic for employers because of the tidal wave of class action lawsuits alleging technical violations of the federal Fair Credit Reporting Act as well as the proliferation of state and local background check laws (including those arising from the Ban the Box movement).

Learn more
Form for a leave of absence on a desktop.
Practice Group

Leaves of Absence/Reasonable Accommodation

Managing leaves and reasonably accommodating employees can be complex, frustrating, and expose employers to legal peril. Employers must navigate a bewildering array of state and federal statutes, with seemingly contradictory mandates.

Learn more
Busy Office : Computer laptop with financial graph data on table in the office
Practice Group

Pay Equity

Recent high-profile lawsuits and increased activity from state legislatures have thrust pay equity issues to the forefront for today’s employers. As the momentum of legislation, regulation, and corporate initiatives focused on identifying and correcting pay disparities continues to grow, our attorneys are ready to assist with the full spectrum of pay equity-related issues.

Learn more
Large open space office
Practice Group

RIF/WARN

Whether it’s a change in a client’s existing business structure, the acquisition of another entity, or a downturn in an economic sector, the attorneys in the Ogletree Deakins’ RIF/WARN Practice Group have extensive experience working with businesses in almost every industry.

Learn more
Practice Group

Employee Benefits and Executive Compensation

Ogletree Deakins has one of the largest teams of employee benefits and executive compensation practitioners in the United States. As part of a firm that focuses on labor and employment law, our Employee Benefits Practice Group has a special ability to relate technical experience to the client’s “big picture” issues.

Learn more
Practice Group

OFCCP Compliance, Government Contracting, and Reporting

The experienced attorneys in our OFCCP Compliance, Government Contracting, and Reporting Practice Group advise and defend federal contractors and subcontractors on jurisdictional, compliance, and enforcement issues relevant to government contracting, including those involving the Office of Federal Contract Compliance Programs (OFCCP).

Learn more
conference room
Practice Group

Arbitration and Alternative Dispute Resolution

Employment arbitration and other alternative dispute resolution (ADR) techniques can help employers and employees achieve quicker and more efficient resolutions to employment disputes. Using ADR, especially arbitration, can reduce the burden and expense of litigation while maintaining fairness to all parties.

Learn more
Modern dark data center, all objects in the scene are 3D
Practice Group

Cybersecurity and Privacy

The attorneys in the Cybersecurity and Privacy Practice Group at Ogletree Deakins understand that data now accumulates quickly and transmits easily. As the law adapts to technical advancements, we effectively advise our clients as they work to comply with new developments and best practices for protecting the privacy of the data that their businesses collect and retain.

Learn more
Steps to the United States Supreme Court, Washington DC, America
Practice Group

Appellate

At Ogletree Deakins, our appellate attorneys know that appeals court rulings can affect our clients’ industries as a whole. Ogletree Deakins’ appellate work has made a global impact in several industries. Our appellate victory regarding the interpretation of the federal Mine Safety and Health Act (MSHA) was a boon to the entire mining industry.

Learn more
Practice Group

Class Action

Our class action lawyers are veterans. We have decades of experience handling numerous types of federal and state law class and collective actions, such as those arising under Title VII, the Age Discrimination in Employment Act, the Employee Retirement Income Security Act, and the Fair Labor Standards Act.

Learn more
A deaf man with his back turned
Practice Group

Disability Access

The lawyers in Ogletree Deakins’ Disability Access Practice Group have extensive experience helping their clients face the multiple challenges presented by Title III of the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) and other disability access laws. From defending class actions, to ensuring compliance with federal and state building standards-thereby eliminating the conditions that lead to litigation-to navigating the complicated regulations covering service animals, hotel reservations, ticketing, and Segways, our work is comprehensive.

Learn more
Practice Group

Drug Testing

Ogletree Deakins understands that employers face complex and nuanced issues when implementing and enforcing drug and alcohol testing and substance abuse policies. Drawing on decades of experience advising and defending drug testing laboratories, and public and private employers across the country and internationally, our attorneys provide highly responsive legal service

Learn more
Practice Group

Employment Law

Ogletree Deakins’ employment lawyers are experienced in all aspects of employment law, from day-to-day advice to complex employment litigation.

Learn more
Practice Group

ERISA Litigation

Ogletree Deakins has one of the largest teams of employee benefits, executive compensation, and Employee Retirement Income Security Act (ERISA) litigation practitioners in the United States. As part of a firm that focuses on labor and employment law, Ogletree Deakins’ ERISA Litigation Practice Group applies technical litigation experience and employee benefits knowledge to clients’ needs.

Learn more
Practice Group

Ethics Compliance and Whistleblower Response

Ogletree Deakins provides clients with innovative and business-oriented solutions to compliance issues across every facet of labor and employment law. Our lawyers work with clients to design effective compliance measures, assist in audits and investigations, and defend clients in relation to compliance as well as retaliation claims.

Learn more
New York City, NY, USA - October 11, 2017: American flag flapping in front of corporate office building in Lower Manhattan
Practice Group

Governmental Affairs

Ogletree Governmental Affairs, Inc. (OGA), a subsidiary of Ogletree Deakins, is a full service legislative and regulatory affairs consulting firm, dedicated to helping clients solve their problems with the public sector. OGA unites the skills and experience of government relations professionals with the talent of the Firm’s lawyers to provide solutions to regulatory issues outside the courtroom.

Learn more
Close up of american visa label in passport. SHallow depth of field.
Practice Group

Immigration

Ogletree Deakins has one of the largest business immigration practices in the United States and provides a wide range of legal services for employers seeking temporary business visas and permanent residence on behalf of foreign national employees.

Learn more
Glass globe representing international business and trade
Practice Group

Cross-Border

Often, a company’s employment issues are not isolated to one state, country, or region of the world. Our Cross-Border Practice Group helps clients with matters worldwide—whether involving a single non-U.S. jurisdiction or dozens.

Learn more
Writing instrument and stack of papers paperwork on office desk table. With copy space. Shot with ISO64.
Practice Group

Litigation

Ogletree Deakins’ litigation practice continues to expand with each new employment right or legal obligation created by legislatures or the courts. Our litigators have significant experience handling complex employment cases, including class and collective actions.

Learn more
Street protest against war in Ukraine in town square.
Practice Group

Traditional Labor Relations

The attorneys in Ogletree Deakins’ Traditional Labor Practice Group have vast experience in complex and sophisticated traditional labor law matters. This includes experience advising and representing employers of all sizes and across virtually all industries in connection with union representation campaigns, collective bargaining negotiations, strike preparations, labor arbitrations, and National Labor Relations Board proceedings.

Learn more
Silhouette shadows of business people talking in office
Practice Group

Unfair Competition and Trade Secrets

We know your business. We know what makes it valuable. We make it our business to protect your assets and goodwill. Every day, our Unfair Competition and Trade Secrets Practice Group—comprised of more than 100 lawyers—leverages our deep bench, experience, and efficiency-built technology and litigation support to partner with companies of all sizes, from small businesses to Fortune 100 companies.

Learn more
Weekly Time Sheet
Practice Group

Wage and Hour

Ogletree Deakins’ Wage and Hour Practice Group features attorneys who are experienced in advising and representing employers in a wide range of wage and hour issues, and who are located in Ogletree Deakins’ offices across the country.

Learn more
Businessmen walking and talking in empty warehouse
Practice Group

Workplace Safety and Health

The Occupational Safety and Health (OSH) practice of Ogletree Deakins is characterized by the knowledge and credibility of our attorneys, and the exceptional level of service that we provide to our clients.

Learn more
Industry Group

Airline and Railway

Few industries feel the burden of today’s laws and regulations more keenly than our nation’s airlines and railroads. Ogletree Deakins’ Airline and Railway Industry Group attorneys understand the unique challenges of these complex businesses.

Learn more
Midsection of senior woman and female healthcare worker with hands stacked at retirement home
Industry Group

Healthcare

The attorneys in Ogletree Deakins’ Healthcare Industry Group understand the unique legal challenges facing healthcare industry clients that must balance vital and demanding work with numerous compliance regimes and heavy regulation.

Learn more
A modern university lecture hall full of students listening to the lecturer.
Practice Group

Higher Education

Ogletree Deakins is an industry leader in higher education legal practice. Our attorneys have decades of experience advising and defending public and private, religious and secular colleges, universities, and vocational schools.

Learn more
Beautiful modern hotel room and suitcase
Industry Group

Hospitality

Ogletree Deakins’ Hospitality practice is as diverse as the clients we serve. From bed-and-breakfast inns to destination resorts, and from fast casual restaurants to fine dining concepts, we understand our clients’ needs and challenges and share their commitment to providing exceptional quality, service, and value.

Learn more
Scientist pipetting a sample into a petri dish during a experiment in the laboratory
Industry Group

Life Sciences

Our attorneys have decades of experience representing publicly and privately held companies in the broad range of life sciences businesses, including those devoted to biotechnology, medical devices research and manufacturing, medical information data collection and storage, medical software and informatics, laboratory and medical testing, medical research, and others focused on research, development, technology, and manufacturing.

Learn more
Inside a large shopping mall in Almaty
Industry Group

Retail

Ogletree Deakins is a retail industry leader with clients ranging from brick-and-mortar retailers to online merchants, and small businesses to Fortune 500 corporations. We represent companies in a range of retail sectors, including but not limited to: discount stores, department stores, luxury retailers, home goods and specialty stores, home improvement centers, grocers, pharmacies, online retailers…

Learn more
Team of happy female soccer players celebrating their achievement on a playing field at sunset.
Industry Group

Sports and Entertainment

Ogletree Deakins lawyers understand the complexities and nuances of sports and entertainment businesses. We regularly provide advice and education to clients on sports and entertainment-related legal topics. We also understand the pace of the industry and the vital importance of keeping our clients on stage or on the field.

Learn more

Sign up to receive emails about new developments and upcoming programs.

Sign Up Now