Announcer: Welcome to the Ogletree Deakins podcast, where we provide listeners with brief discussions about important workplace legal issues. Our podcasts are for informational purposes only and should not be construed as legal advice. You can subscribe through your favorite podcast service. Please consider rating this podcast so we can get your feedback and improve our programs. Please enjoy the podcast.
Shir Fulga: Hi everyone. Welcome to another episode of our Canadian Ogletree podcast about employment, labor, and privacy laws in the great white north. My name is Shir Fulga. I’m a lawyer at the Ogletree Toronto, Canada office. And as always, I’m joined by my colleague, Erin Schachter in our Montreal office. Today’s special guest is Perry Yung in our Toronto office.
Hi, Perry. Thank you for being here.
Perry Yung: Hi, thank you so much for having me.
Erin Schachter: Yeah, thank you so much, Perry. And if I understand correctly, this is Erin Schachter speaking from the Montreal office. Today we’re going to be discussing a case that’s called Gentleman v. Kings County that was before the Supreme Court of Nova Scotia. And this is actually based on an article that you wrote that’s available on our blog, which I love the title, it’s, “The Nova Scotia Case of the Unionized Employee Who Didn’t Work a Single Day: Gentleman v. Kings County.” I think this is a great title and a very interesting case.
Would you mind, Perry, to just walk us through a bit the facts of the case and why this is relevant?
Perry Yung: Yes. Thank you, Erin. I will mention that I’m in the Toronto office, but I am called to the bar in Ontario and Nova Scotia, as well. So that’s why this case is particularly interesting to me. So, in this matter, Ms. Gentleman, the employee, had been offered a full-time permanent position as a planner with a municipality of the County of Kings with a start date of January 18th. The employer had actually sent an email to all municipality staff and the union president announcing that she would be joining the team. But then just two days before she was set to begin, the municipality rescinded the offer, citing that the match was not appropriate due to a different planning approach.
Employer also relied on a clause in the contract that said the offer employment was conditional upon the completion of all applicable background checks and confirmation of credentials. And if those weren’t satisfactory, the employer could terminate the employment. So, Ms. Gentleman brought a claim against the municipality for wrongful dismissal, breach of contract, breach of the duty of honest and good faith, contractual performance and negligent misrepresentation in the Supreme Court of Nova Scotia. She wanted the case heard at court and not through a labor arbitrator. She argued that the grievance and arbitration process would not provide her with an effective remedy because she was out of time to file a grievance. The municipality filed a motion to dismiss, arguing that the dispute belonged in the exclusive jurisdiction of a labor arbitration and not in court.
So, the court was left to decide the correct avenue for Ms. Gentleman and zeroed in on the language of the collective agreement. The language in the collective agreement stated and defined employee as an employee in the bargaining unit and it was covered by the collective agreement. Then it also defined “probationary employee” as an employee who had been hired but had not completed the six-month probationary period. And also, another article stated that the probationary employee may be dismissed during the probationary period without the employer having to prove just cause, et cetera. So, the collective agreement clearly laid out based on its language that an employee that was just hired that had not completed the six-month probationary period was still an employee under the collective agreement. So that proved decisive in this matter.
The collective agreement drew a clear distinction between being hired and actually commencing work. This suggested that the employment status can exist before the first day on the job. So, since Ms. Gentleman was hired as a full-time permanent position of planner, and the position of planner was in the bargaining unit and was covered by the collective agreement, she was considered an employee, and she fell within the definition of probationary employee. So, the court decided that this matter fell within the exclusive jurisdiction of a labor arbitrator and that the Supreme Court of Nova Scotia had no jurisdiction to hear this application.
And I think a lot of people were kind of shocked by the decision. However, there was a decision in New Brunswick from 2003 called Re City of Saint John and Saint John Firefighters Association that reached a similar conclusion. So, this isn’t a very novel decision by the Supreme Court of Nova Scotia. It’s been done before.
Shir Fulga: That’s really interesting. As always or as we often see, the language of the collective agreement is really important. And I think here we’re talking about really a single word, an employee who is hired, which kind of brought the employee within the jurisdiction or the exclusive jurisdiction of labor arbitration. And by filing wrongful dismissal suit in court and not following the time limits in the collective agreement for filing a grievance, I assume, and we don’t know this from the decision in the Supreme Court as far as I can tell, she was essentially left without remedy because she filed a suit in the wrong jurisdiction. So that is on its face, a fairly maybe prizing decision.
But I hear you, Perry, that at the end of the day, parties are free, and by parties I mean unions and employers are free to bring into the collective agreement whatever language they see fit. And that’s going to have significant impact on whether something would ever fall within the jurisdiction of the court, which in the normal case it wouldn’t. So, I think that’s a great summary of the decision.
Do you have any final thoughts and maybe takeaway for employers for this one?
Perry Yung: Yeah. So, employers can decide whether they think it’s better to be in the exclusive jurisdiction of a labor board or to have a matter proceed in court. But what they should know and what an employer needs to know is that the language in the collective agreement is very important and that they can negotiate what that language is. So, if they prefer the court, they can negotiate that in, or if they prefer labor board, they can negotiate that in. They need to pay particular attention to the language in the collective agreement. So, they can propose probationary period language that excludes the employees from the CBA until a certain number of weeks of service. Something like that would likely resolve the issue in this matter.
Erin Schachter: So basically, just to kind of sum this up, employers can have some discretion in terms of how they want to approach this issue, but it would be potentially an interesting thing for them to consider when they go into negotiations of any collective agreement to determine what approach they do want to take. Is that an accurate sum up for you, Perry?
Perry Yung: Yes. So, before they get into negotiations with the union, they should have strategized this with their team and decide what they want and their goals when they actually get to the collective bargaining.
Erin Schachter: Thank you so much, Perry, for your time today. And this was really interesting. Shir, I know that you work quite a bit in labor law as well. Is there any last tidbit that you want to add onto that?
Shir Fulga: No, I think Perry summed it up really well. I think that at the end of the day, language in the collective agreement is king. There’s going to be a lot of deference coming from the court when it comes to employees who are covered by the collective agreement. And I think there is going to be always a presumption that something falls within the jurisdiction of a labor arbitrator. So, the more I think about this decision, the more I think it really makes sense and kind of falls in line with what we would expect here. But yeah, no, I think that’s a really nice little decision for employers and for labor lawyers to kind of nod. So, thank you, Perry.
Perry Yung: Thank you so much for having me.
Shir Fulga: And thanks everyone for tuning in and listening. We’ll be back with another episode soon.
Announcer: Thank you for joining us on the Ogletree Deakins podcast. You can subscribe to our podcast on Apple Podcasts or through your favorite podcast service. Please consider rating and reviewing so that we may continue to provide the content that covers your needs. And remember, the information in this podcast is for informational purposes only and is not to be construed as legal advice.