Flag of Germany

Quick Hits

  • The general works council’s right to codetermine the use of a company-wide time tracking system does not automatically cover the information rights of local works councils.
  • A general works council may regulate local works councils’ access to personal working time data only if the local works councils have authorized it to do so.
  • Permanent read-only access to working time data for works councils can raise data protection concerns if the reasons for various employee absences allow conclusions about employees’ health.

The Case: Read-Only Access to Working Time Data

The employer had concluded a company-wide works agreement with its general works council on the human resources management system “LOGA.” The employer used the system to record working hours, time accounts, and reasons for absence, among other things. The local works councils received electronic read-only access to the system for monitoring purposes.

A data protection incident triggered the dispute. A local works council had employees’ sick days compiled in an unencrypted spreadsheet file on an internal drive. In response, the employer revoked the access rights of all local works councils.

The general works council demanded that access be restored. In the alternative, it requested limited access to the data without certain reasons for absence, such as information on illness, rehabilitation stays, or maternity leave.

No Right of the General Works Council to Enforce the Agreement

The LAG dismissed the appeal. The introduction and use of a time-tracking system that records data on employee conduct or performance is generally subject to codetermination under Section 87(1) No. 6 of the Works Constitution Act (Betriebsverfassungsgesetz (BetrVG)). Because the employer used the system throughout the company, the general works council was responsible for codetermination on its introduction and use.

However, the court found that this competence did not automatically cover every issue connected with the system. Local works councils’ access to working time data concerns their own monitoring and information rights under Section 80 of the BetrVG. Local works councils can exercise these rights at the establishment level, even when the system is used company-wide.

Under Section 50(2) of the BetrVG, the local works councils would have had to delegate the exercise of their rights under Section 80 of the BetrVG to the general works council for a company-wide rule. There was no such delegation.

The LAG left open the question of whether employers can generally grant local works councils their own access rights in a company-wide works agreement. In any case, the employer could not implement the agreement in favor of the local works councils. Read-only access would create not only rights but also data protection obligations for the local works councils. The local works councils had not agreed to take on these obligations.

Data Protection Limits on Permanent Access

Even read-only access is a processing of personal data under the EU General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR).

The stored reasons for absence were particularly sensitive. Information on rehabilitation stays or maternity leave allowed conclusions about the health of the employees concerned. This made it health data. As a result, the stricter requirements of Article 9 of the GDPR and Section 26(3) of the Federal Data Protection Act (Bundesdatenschutzgesetz (BDSG)) applied.

In the court’s view, permanent access to these records for monitoring purposes, without any specific reason, was not necessary. Section 80(2) of the BetrVG gives works councils a right to the information and the documents they need to perform their duties. However, this does not include permanent online access to an entire database.

In response to a specific request for information, an employer can examine which data the council actually needs for the task at hand. Unlimited system access would largely eliminate this right of review.

The company-wide works agreement did not justify the access either. Processing the specially protected data was not necessary in the employment context, and the employees concerned had not consented.

No Right to a New Data View

The alternative request also failed. The existing agreement did not provide for access that hid individual reasons for absences. In addition, the employer would first have had to commission programming for this limited view. The works councils’ right to information under Section 80 of the BetrVG did not go that far.

According to the court, the right to information does not require an employer to create new documents or to technically modify an existing system.

Outlook and Takeaways

This decision does not mean that works councils may never receive working time data. However, the court drew a clear line between information needed for a specific case and permanent, comprehensive system access. The court also made clear that Section 87(1) No. 6 of the BetrVG alone does not allow a general works council to regulate local works councils’ access to personal data for monitoring purposes.

Companies may want to review access authorization concepts for human resources and time-tracking systems regularly. Access protocols may be role-based, purpose-limited, and designed to minimize data. A general works agreement also cannot change these principles.

Ogletree Deakins’ Munich office will continue to monitor developments and will provide updates on the Cross-Border, Cybersecurity and Privacy, and Germany blogs as additional information becomes available.

Follow and Subscribe
LinkedIn | Instagram | Webinars | Podcasts

Author


Browse More Insights

Modern dark data center, all objects in the scene are 3D
Practice Group

Cybersecurity and Privacy

The attorneys in the Cybersecurity and Privacy Practice Group at Ogletree Deakins understand that data now accumulates quickly, transmits easily, and—increasingly—is processed by artificial intelligence (AI) systems that introduce new dimensions of legal risk. 

Learn more
Glass globe representing international business and trade
Practice Group

Cross-Border

Often, a company’s employment issues are not isolated to one state, country, or region of the world. Our Cross-Border Practice Group helps clients with matters worldwide—whether involving a single non-U.S. jurisdiction or many more. 

Learn more

Sign up to receive emails about new developments and upcoming programs.

Sign Up Now